.

Blog: Commissioners Ethics Challenged (Update)

“Who is the County Attorney’s client?” This is the first question asked by State Senator Joe Getty of the County Commissioners.

Neil Ridgely amended several bullet points in this blog to acknowledge that the commissioners did discuss this topic in an open meeting. The information that has been added is in italics. The meeting can be viewed here: http://carrollcountymd.iqm2.com/citizens/SplitView.aspx?Mode=Video&MeetingID=1643&AgendaID=1515&FileFormat=pdf&Format=Agenda&MediaFileFormat=wmv


“Who is the County Attorney’s client?” This is the first question asked by State Senator Joe Getty when discussing the law suit that 3 of the County Commissioners have filed against the State of Maryland over the statewide redistricting plan.It’s a very important question and one that I feel should make citizens very angry that it had to be raised in a public meeting.

The County video of that meeting is very telling as you will see Commissioner Howard become quite annoyed with Getty for raising the issue and then trying to shut the discussion down so it could be further discussed in a back room. It runs about five minutes and can be found at this link by advancing the button below the video screen to the 1 hour 57 minute mark to cut to the chase:http://carrollcountymd.iqm2.com/citizens/SplitView.aspx?Mode=Video&MeetingID=1644&MinutesID=1412&FileFormat=pdf&Format=Minutes&MediaFileFormat=wmv

Caught in the middle of all this is County Attorney who has to do what he is told if he is to keep his appointed position, regardless of whether he believes there is validity to the suit or not. He was directed to file the suit by a majority of theCommissioners and so he has, as he should. Now his office may bear the brunt of the considerable time and expense of the lawsuit (remember that $200,000 political/legal slush fund the Commish created when elected?). My guess is that the Commish intend to off this case onto a local, politically favored law firm at $450 an hour as they did in a recent ethics hearing.

In as brief an outline as I can make of this issue I am actually going to use some of the arguments presented by Senator Getty at the meeting on this past Thursday; bear in mind that Getty & Commissioner Shoemaker were the only attorneys present in the room at the time of the meeting:

  • This is a matter of politics far more than it is one of governance. Howard, Rothschild and Roush can try to paint it as one of governance but that argument fails the smell-o-meter test.Why are the Commissioners getting involved in a state districtingmatter? The redistricting has no effect on the County Commissioner'selection districts. The so-called gored bulls here are the Carroll Delegates.
  • Does the County Attorney work for the citizens of Carroll County,the Board of Commissioners, the Legislative Delegation or threeCommissioners with a political axe to grind?The 3 members of the Carroll Delegation, Stocksdale, Krebs & Elliot are the only ones in the delegation filing suit and they are doing so individually, or so it appears but then Getty points out that if they are filing suit individually, what the heck is the County Attorney doing carrying their water for them?
  • If 3 Commissioners feel so compelled as to sue the state over the redistricting they should personally file the suit, not use their elective office, public funds and the County Attorney to do so.The County is legally prevented from suing the State of Maryland.In so many words, one arm of government is prevented from suing the body.
  • The Commissioners use of the County Attorney to file this suit is probably a violation of the County Ethics law (Howard retorted that Gettywould have to ask the County Attorney this question!) 
  • The agenda for their May 1, 2012 meeting indicated only “Possible vote on redistricting petition.” This intentionally vague agenda assured them a vacant audience that day. It is obvious that County Attorney Tim Burke had been directed to come to that meeting with a Power Point presentation in hand and was there to solely discuss filing a suit against the state. In fact Commissioner Howard tries to cover up just how the item got on the agenda by claiming that he asked to have it put on when he is interrupted by Commissioner Rothschild who states that he issued the “Goldenrod” on this matter. There is much more to be found out about the secret “Goldenrod form of Communication the Commissioners and County staff have been using behind closed doors.
  • Only now have the Commissioners issued a last-minute amendment to their agenda for May 10th to include an item, “Discussion and vote to require a separate vote with public input if outside cost exceeds $1000.00 on redistricting lawsuit.” So we now have a vote to vote on whether the public should be allowed input. Isn’t that revealing?
  • Individuals from Frederick and Carroll Counties have shown the legal way to go about filing a lawsuit over redistricting. Although I do not agree with them, these individuals have put their personal money where their mouths are by hiring an attorney and filing a suit in the Court of Appeals. It is their personal action and their personal funds that they have put on the line, not mine and yours.
  • The most revealing part of the Commissioners discussion on the suit came when the usually clueless Robin Frazier commented that the three delegates who are offended by the redistricting have wanted Carroll County Government to file this lawsuit because they did not want to personally pay for the costs out of their own pockets.
  • The Commissioners are using public treasury funds to satiate their personal political ambitions. Significant staff time and funds will be spent if the Commissioners proceed to use the office of the County Attorney to sue. Senator Getty's knowledgable estimate is that a suit in the Court of Special Appeals will run into hundreds of hours and costs between $20,000 and $30,000 at a minimum if staff attorneys are taken from their usual duties to stand before a Master and / or court. He cited a recent example when the Republican Party sued the State and the cost exceeded $200,000 in legal fees.
  • Is the suit about winning a legal argument or about entrenching a political profile for these Commissioners? If there are citizens who feel wronged by the redistricting, they are allowed to file suit against the State, at their time and expense.The Office of the County Attorney is not an Office of People's Counsel and should not be maneuvered by politicians as acting as such.The County Attorney is being asked to serve the interests of 6 individuals rather than that of the the citizens of Carroll. They want to use taxpayers money to front the legal fees rather than dig into their own pockets, thus putting their money where their mouths are.
  • The MD Attorney General may have the ability to dismiss the suit on the grounds that the County hasn’t the ability to sue the State.

The 3 Commissioners decision to use public funds for personal, political purposes should be reversed. I suggest that those outraged with this decision begin with telling Attorney General Gansler and also sending messages to each of the Commissioners. Please be aware that Commissioner Shoemaker voted against the lawsuit; Commissioner Rob’em Frazier recused herself from the vote using her usual clueless reason that she had not had time to read up on the matter.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

David A. Grand May 05, 2012 at 03:11 PM
Rest easy,Neil.For while zealots often carry the day; they seldom, if ever, persevere.
Bonnie Grady May 05, 2012 at 03:18 PM
If you live in Carroll County, you owe it to yourself to click on that link and watch that 5-minute video. Senator Getty spells it out very clearly. The three commissioners who signed onto this are violated their oath of office in which they swore to uphold the laws of the State of Maryland; they cannot legally turn around and file suit against the State, as Getty explains. The same is true for the three members of the Carroll County House Delegation who signed onto it; they cannot swear to uphold the law and then file suit when they disagree with a new law. Whatever they do as individuals is their business; what they do with our tax money, using county staff and county resources is OUR business. Please, make it YOUR business to take five minutes to learn about this issue and then speak up!
Bonnie Grady May 05, 2012 at 03:29 PM
Here is a simple email that you can copy and paste. Send it to Senator Getty at this address: joseph.getty@senate.state.md.us Dear Senator Getty, I am a citizen of Carroll County. I am opposed to the lawsuit filed by certain members of our Carroll County Board of Commissioners and House Delegation regarding the new redistricting plan. Whether I agree or disagree with the redistricting plan is not the issue here. What I oppose is the flagrant misuse of county funds (possibly in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, as you pointed out), county staff time, and county resources. In these tough economic times, we need leaders who will use our resources wisely on things like schools and roads and the environment. We don't need leaders who are bent on chasing their own political windmills at taxpayer expense. I urge you to continue your outspoken opposition to this frivolous action and respectfully request that you further explore the possibility of ethics violations on the part of those elected officials who have choosen to take part in the lawsuit. Thank you. (Add your name here)
Bonnie Grady May 05, 2012 at 04:36 PM
And be sure to read the related article on Patch. It's at: http://westminster.patch.com/articles/sen-getty-questions-ethics-of-carroll-county-s-lawsuit
Buck Harmon May 05, 2012 at 11:44 PM
Of course Shoemaker voted against it...he's a lawyer..he has been aware of laws being broken since this group took office. I can't forget the fact that he cost Hampstead taxpayers almost a million dollars in legal fees trying to take private property by the use of eminent domain. Did Shoemaker inform his fellow commissioners that what they were doing was wrong, or just lay low...knowing....?
Bonnie Grady May 06, 2012 at 12:34 AM
Buck, did you watch that video?
Buck Harmon May 06, 2012 at 02:27 AM
I did watch the end of the video..when Getty addressed the issue with the Commissioners and Howard just wanted it to end... I started at the beginning, watching Rothschild stuff his face with donuts and then sneezing on Shoemaker...couldn't stand it..
romeo valianti May 06, 2012 at 04:20 PM
this law suit is being orchestrated by none others than Delegate Susan Krebs, Doug Howard, Stocksdale, Elliott and maybe a few more hanger ons that are frustated they are the minority party in Annapolis, I say hooray for Governor Martin O'Malley, President Of The Senate Mile Miller and SpeakerOf The House Michael Busch.
Buck Harmon May 07, 2012 at 01:54 PM
That split second look on Shoemakers face...just after the sneeze was priceless though...
Hugh Manatee May 07, 2012 at 07:09 PM
Thank you Neil and thank you for Patch for covering this. Not a word of it in the Carroll Co Times.
Bonnie Grady May 08, 2012 at 04:07 AM
Well, Commissioners, be careful what you ask for! In demanding that Patch instruct Neil Ridgely to amend his blogpost, you have dared him to cast a much brighter light on the deception and lies that you as a board continue to employ. And once again, Neil does not disappoint. Commissioners, your arrogance is beyond belief. Your inability to govern openly and honestly is disgraceful. On this one, however, kudos to Commissioner Shoemaker for having the good sense to separate himself from this unethical, possibly illegal, conduct. The rest of you should be ashamed. (Good to know you're still reading Patch, Mr. Howard!)
Bonnie Grady May 08, 2012 at 04:28 AM
If you are outraged about the county commissioners wasting YOUR tax money to file this unethical and possibly illegal lawsuit against the state, scroll up on this page. In an earlier post you will see a short message that you can copy and paste into an email to Senator Getty. His email address is provided just above the message. Please take a moment to do this. As Senator Getty alluded to, this latest stunt by the commissioners could end up costing Carroll County taxpayers tens of thousands, possibly hundreds of thousands, of dollars. Please email Senator Getty now!
Bonnie Grady May 09, 2012 at 05:07 AM
See it with your own eyes. Hear it with your own ears. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyPcylCK3Io
Edmund Burke May 12, 2012 at 01:18 AM
"Commissioner Rob’em Frazier recused herself from the vote using her usual clueless reason that she had not had time to read up on the matter." She is blessed with a combination of laziness and stupidity that will deliver her from tribulation.

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something